Miss Mae's Bake Shoppe

Miss Mae's Bake ShoppeMiss Mae's Bake ShoppeMiss Mae's Bake Shoppe

Miss Mae's Bake Shoppe

Miss Mae's Bake ShoppeMiss Mae's Bake ShoppeMiss Mae's Bake Shoppe
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Gallery
  • Our Story
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • More
    • Home
    • Menu
    • Gallery
    • Our Story
    • FAQ
    • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Gallery
  • Our Story
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us

Menu / Price List

Custom Cake Order

Filled Round Layer Cakes with Custom Decoration

6" Round Cake (6-8 servings)

$22

2-3 layers 

9" Round Cake (10-14 servings)

$44

3-4 layers with filling if desired

10" Fillable Cake (12 servings)

$66

2 layers of sponge with pockets of hidden treats in each slice

1/4 Sheet Cake (24 servings)

$50

2 layers of sponge with frosting 

Custom fillings available upon request

1/2 Sheet Cake (48 servings)

$75

2 layers of sponge with frosting

Custom fillings available upon request


Custom Cupcake Order

Delicious Cupcakes with Custom Decoration

Standard

$25

Scrumptious, beautifully decorated cupcakes

One dozen per box (12 count)

A pair for $9 (cupcakes are better when shared)

Miniature

$14

Sweet & petite! A delicious, fun dessert option for all types of celebrations. 

One dozen per box (12 count)

Minimum 48-hour notice is required for all orders. Special orders shall be subject to 10% upcharge depending are ingredients required.

Flavors, Fillings, Frosting

Sponge Flavors

Sponge Flavors

Sponge Flavors

White

Vanilla

Chocolate

Lemon

Strawberry

Confetti

Yellow

Cake Fillings

Sponge Flavors

Sponge Flavors

Fruit & Jams (berries)

Candies

Confectionery Candies

Peanut Butter
Cream Cheese
Lemon Crème
Custom Fillings Available 

Frosting

Sponge Flavors

Frosting

Vanilla Butter Cream
Chocolate Butter Cream
Cream Cheese
Ganache
Whipped Topping 

Menu / Price List

Classic Cake Order

Traditional Favorites from everyone's 1988 Church Cookbook

Red Velvet

$39

Available in 9" (3 layers) 

This cake is soft and tangy and has a personality of its own and pairs perfectly with cream cheese frosting.

Carrot Cake

$41

Available in 9" (3 layers) 

Hand-grating carrots is a labor of love giving this recipe the ultimate carrot flavor and delicate texture we love in our cake covered in a luscious cream cheese frosting.


More Guilty Pleasures

Flavors for treats upon request

Cake Pops

$27

Bite-size treats made from a fully baked cake or brownie that is crumbled, hand-rolled in a ball then dipped in candy coating.  Fun for any celebration - birthday, promotion, A- on an exam, new homeowner! The possibilities are endless!

One dozen per box (two flavors) (12 count)

Brownies

$24

Nothing says “I love chocolate” better than brownies. 

Are you for team fudge? Or team chewy? Try both to decide!

One dozen per box (12 count) 

Classic Drop Cookies

$24

Classic drop cookies including chocolate chip, monster mash, circus birthday and candy bar.  Soft in the center, crispy edges and weighing in at 40 grams each!

One dozen per box  (12 count) 

Covered Strawberries

$35

Each berry is delicately hand dipped & decorated, then carefully packaged in a beautiful gift box. 

One dozen per box (two flavors) (12 count) 

*Price subject to change due to local cost of raw materials

Minimum 48-hour notice is required for all orders. Special orders shall be subject to 10% upcharge depending are ingredients required.

Calories? I believe you mean delicious points

Copyright © 2022 Miss Mae's Bake Shoppe - All Rights Reserved.  

Registered Cottage Food Producer in Indiana 

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept